Reply
   
 Big time CIO tests the OS's and gives kudos to OS X 
 
 
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 29-11-2006, 01:37 PM
Regular

Group: Regulars
Location: Melbourne
Blog Entries: 5


Big time CIO tests the OS's and gives kudos to OS X

The CIO of the Harvard Medical School and CareGroup, John Halamka, got tired of Windows security updates interrupting his business so he spent a month working on each OS (OS X, Red Hat's Fedora Core Linux and Windows XP) and published his findings in CIO magazine.

It's an interesting read, especially for those who prefer Macs but are forced to use Windows at work.

As an OS he gives OS X full credit for it's usabilty and reliablility and has now chosen a Mac for his home computing needs. He has also opened up the computer purchasing policies to include Macs.

Halamka says testing alternatives to XP has been a valuable exercise because it made him realize that the Mac can be a viable computing platform for enterprise users.

His dislikes were not actually for OS X itself but included Entourage's synchronisation with MS Exchange (storing all his 3Gb of email to the hard drive took a day). Some IE-centric websites in the medical industry not working with Safari because they use Active X. He found getting XP to work in Bootcamp "finiky". And "some of the functions one takes for granted on PCs, such as printing screen shots and right clicking, aren't obvious on Macs"

Not OS related but worth noting is his concerns for the weight of the MacBook and the heat it generated.

His closing comments were: "If Apple comes up with a 2- or 2.5-pound 12-inch-screen laptop that runs cool, has better integration with Exchange, and if Vista turns out to be the beast it could be, then I probably will move to a Mac."
__________________
My blog: Distractful

Just remember that even without the drugs you still have sex and rock n' roll. That should be enough for anyone. Sean Fallon, Gizmodo

Last edited by Bart Smastard; 29-11-2006 at 01:46 PM. Reason: formatting
Bart Smastard is offline
Profile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
Reply With Quote
  #2 (permalink)  
Old 29-11-2006, 02:00 PM
Stuck in IKEA. Send help.

Group: Administrators
Location: St. Albans, Melbourne
Blog Entries: 11


"some of the functions one takes for granted on PCs, such as printing screen shots and right clicking, aren't obvious on Macs"

hahaha, right clicking isn't obvious (then get a mouse with a right mouse button) and a screenshot - well, it's not exactly obvious on Windows either (print screen? what?)

In the context of the article though, he raises a good point of not wanting to retrain users. A lot of people are just used to rote learning things in Windows - move the mouse to a certain area and click. Move these things and change the style of doing things instead of understanding a concept and being able to apply it to different situations. Users will be frustrated and long for their Windows boxes

Last edited by decryption; 29-11-2006 at 02:04 PM.
decryption is offline
Profile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old 29-11-2006, 03:30 PM
Member

Group: Regulars
Location: Sydney


Arrow

hehehe, once upon a time i used to think that the print screen button did exactly that, sent the screen to the printer
brooksaar is offline
Profile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
Reply With Quote
eni
  #4 (permalink)  
Old 29-11-2006, 03:41 PM
Regular

Group: Regulars
Location: Sydney


Quote:
Originally Posted by brooksaar View Post
hehehe, once upon a time i used to think that the print screen button did exactly that, sent the screen to the printer
Once upon a time, it did.
eni is offline
Profile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old 29-11-2006, 04:01 PM
Regular

Group: Regulars
Location: Melbourne
Blog Entries: 5


Quote:
Originally Posted by decryption View Post
"some of the functions one takes for granted on PCs, such as printing screen shots and right clicking, aren't obvious on Macs"

hahaha, right clicking isn't obvious (then get a mouse with a right mouse button) and a screenshot - well, it's not exactly obvious on Windows either (print screen? what?)

In the context of the article though, he raises a good point of not wanting to retrain users. A lot of people are just used to rote learning things in Windows - move the mouse to a certain area and click. Move these things and change the style of doing things instead of understanding a concept and being able to apply it to different situations. Users will be frustrated and long for their Windows boxes
Sorry Decryption, I disagree I think even the most hardened Windows user would manage to understand OS X in a reasonably short time.
If they've been using PC's as long as I have they've been through the pain of migrating from DOS to Windows 3.11 to NT to Win 95 to Win 98 to Win 2000 to Win XP.
Then there's the migration from the various so called "productivity" applications: Word Perfect to Lotus 123 to MS Office and maybe even to Lotus Notes. In my experience none of these have been a simple or delightful excercise... especially the Lotus Notes bit .
Where my move to OS X at home has been a lovely experience.
__________________
My blog: Distractful

Just remember that even without the drugs you still have sex and rock n' roll. That should be enough for anyone. Sean Fallon, Gizmodo
Bart Smastard is offline
Profile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old 29-11-2006, 04:40 PM
Regular

Group: Regulars
Location: Canberra


Quote:
Originally Posted by brooksaar View Post
hehehe, once upon a time i used to think that the print screen button did exactly that, sent the screen to the printer
and once upon a time it did!
__________________
Originally Posted by Jimbo:
"Fire + Alcohol + Chemicals = one really hilarious time! "

...Guess I'm Just your typical terrorist!
Jimbo is offline
Profile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 29-11-2006, 05:08 PM
Regular

Group: Regulars
Location: Brisbane


decription: I have long wondered why people learn word or excel and not word processing or spreadsheeting, no one learns how to drive a holden, and then has to relearn to drive a honda. I mean that if they learned the underlying concepts any 'puter becomes much easier to use. Having noted that I was very frustrated the first time I used linux and somewhat frustrated the first time I used OSX.
Bart: you are a pussy if you think any of those programs had a steep learning curve! Any seasoned Lotus Manuscript user will tell you that was the hardest program they ever had to learn (but once you mastered it it was far and away the best word processor, not only in DOS but for years and years after). Its feature set was not matched by word till about v5 and it was much better than WordPerfect, it was just so counter-intuitive to use.

sao
__________________
the answer is yes, I am an old curmudgeon
its not irony, its sarcasm
If you must have the last word, then I suppose you must
antechinus55 is offline
Profile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
Reply With Quote
  #8 (permalink)  
Old 30-11-2006, 09:16 AM
Regular

Group: Regulars
Location: Melbourne
Blog Entries: 5


Quote:
Originally Posted by antechinus55 View Post
decription: I have long wondered why people learn word or excel and not word processing or spreadsheeting, no one learns how to drive a holden, and then has to relearn to drive a honda. I mean that if they learned the underlying concepts any 'puter becomes much easier to use. Having noted that I was very frustrated the first time I used linux and somewhat frustrated the first time I used OSX.
Bart: you are a pussy if you think any of those programs had a steep learning curve! Any seasoned Lotus Manuscript user will tell you that was the hardest program they ever had to learn (but once you mastered it it was far and away the best word processor, not only in DOS but for years and years after). Its feature set was not matched by word till about v5 and it was much better than WordPerfect, it was just so counter-intuitive to use.

sao
A pussy eh!... Yeah that's probably true. My problem is that my first computer was an Amiga 1000, which had an easy to understand GUI and apps that seemed well thought out in respect to usability. Sure it was a little weird to have to first insert the Kick Start disk and then put in the Work Bench disk but that was just part of its character.

Then I started using PC's at work and could not understand why on earth anyone should care about the C:\ prompt. In fact the transition from Amiga to PC was probably the hardest to cope with. Only because one was beautiful and well mannered, the other very ugly and terribly obnoxious.
__________________
My blog: Distractful

Just remember that even without the drugs you still have sex and rock n' roll. That should be enough for anyone. Sean Fallon, Gizmodo
Bart Smastard is offline
Profile CardPM
Go to the top of the page
Reply With Quote
 
Reply

Thread Tools

 
Similar Threads
 
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Macbook playing up big time!! Wally Notebooks 6 08-04-2007 06:38 PM
Toast 7 burning DVDs; files too big but not big enough !? Brewster Mac OS X & All Software 0 18-03-2007 08:31 AM
Mac Pro SLI Tests Maticks Desktop Computers 3 10-08-2006 02:13 PM
Macworld Tests Intel iMac - Not quite 2 x faster macrob69 Desktop Computers 11 19-01-2006 11:22 AM